Is hypocrisy a natural human flaw? - myLot It caused many people, in Salem during this event to think fast, rash and jump to conclusions. This is a decision with dire consequences in a town where reputation is so important, a fact that contributes to the misunderstanding that follows. It is not just, (Miller 129). She attended church regularly and was the embodiment of how a Puritan woman should behave. She comes to me while I sleep; shes always making me dream corruptions! pg. To illustrate this, he simultaneously shows the Puritan belief system while describing characters that do not obey that system, yet pretend to in their daily lives. One path to higher standing and greater control would be in becoming John Proctors wife. He says, I would to God it were not so, Excellency, but these people have great weight yet in the town (pg. . Giles Cory was expelled from court because he would not list people who signed the document about Putnam wanting to take land. Historical Context. Elizabeth's side of the story is disregarded because Abigails testimony is far more dramatic. While I speak Gods law, I will not crack its voice with whimpering (pg. Elizabeth is defined by her relationship to John, and Mary is pushed around by other characters (mostly men) throughout the play. Themes can be expressed in many different ways. There are several ironies in Act 1 that center around Abigail Williams. And he goes to save her, and, stuck two inches in the flesh of her belly, he draw a needle out." How are characters behaviors affected by concern for their reputations? Will you confess yourself with him? (pg. Danforth explains his inability to free the accused people because, twelve are already hanged for the same crime. This leads to Marys hysterical accusation of Proctor after she finds herself targeted by the other girls and about to be consumed by the hysteria herself if she doesnt contribute to it. HypocrisyHuman Nature? | Connor Boyack - Author, Public Speaker Hales involvement is taken to mean that there must be a supernatural element to Bettys illness. The play, The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller demonstrates the implications of a society in complete chaos over an irrational fear of witchcraft in the town of Salem, Massachusetts. Upon arriving in the court Mary Warren says, I cannot lie no more. 41). Nowhere is there any consideration of ulterior motives. Hales involvement is taken to mean that there must be a supernatural element to Bettys illness. The faces that people present to the public are designed to garner respect in the community, but the witch trials have thrown this system into disarray. Hypocrisy In Salem And The Crucible Proctor knows that unlike most of the other people who have gotten hanged, his is not completely innocent. Danforth, Hathorne, and Parris become even more rigid in their views when they feel they are under attack. He is appalled by Elizabeths lack of emotion when he asks her to help the court get a confession out of her husband (pg. Abigails low status and perceived innocence under normal circumstances allow her to claim even greater power in her current situation. She puts on a fake front to get what she wants, ultimately creating a persona thats even worse than that of the hypocrites she criticizes. He wrote the play as an allegory of McCarthyism, when the US government discriminated communists. Is reputation more important than truth? Hypocrisy relates to The Crucible in that both Reverend Parris and Mr. Putnam are incredibly hypocritical characters. Thomas Putnam claims to be a holy, church-going man, yet his priority in life is to acquire land. The play is about human weakness, hypocrisy, and vindictiveness. Danforth explains that witchcraft is an invisible crime and that only the victims are reliable. His only goal is to get on the good side of the community as a whole, even in the midst of this bout of collective hysteria. Ann Putnam jumps at any opportunity to blame supernatural forces for the deaths of her children. Tituba, the slave of Reverend Parris, is the first to admit to dancing with the devil. When Hale asks him to recite his commandments, the only one he forgets is adultery. (Cheever pg. First off, what is irony? Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. Reverend Hale enters as a specialist from Boston who has seen the effects that witchcraft has had on others. These are themes that could be considered subsets of the topics detailed in the previous sections, but there's also room to discuss them as topics in their own right. He insists,I am not empowered to trade your life for a lie (pg. All rights reserved. 129)He is still convinced that all the prisoners are guilty and is determined to force them to admit their guilt. 123). Miller addresses a similar hysteria throughout his play. In the next few sections,I'll take a look at a group of broad themes inThe Crucible, including irony, hysteria, reputation, and power. The fact that he forgets only this commandment shows that he is trying extremely hard to repress his guilt. In this case, you're asked to discuss the concept of a tragic character, explaining who fits that mold in The Crucible and why. What Are The Human Flaws In The Crucible | ipl.org Arthur Miller portrays the protagonist, Proctor, as the tragic hero of his play The Crucible. No one considers that the accusers are lying, partially because theyre seen as innocent children and partially because many witches confess to avoid the death penalty. People were put to death because their neighbors suspected them of committing a crime, but murder is a sin in the Puritan religion. This leads to Marys hysterical accusation of Proctor after she finds herself targeted by the other girls and about to be consumed by the hysteria herself if she doesnt contribute to it. So, she decides to manipulate the situation by saying that the Devil has come to her and she has resisted his commands to kill Mr. Parris. The irony is that, in the face of Johns rejection, Abigail turns around and creates her own lies soon after that give her increased control over the society she resents. Hale tries to combat his guilt by persuading the prisoners to confess, refusing to accept that the damage has already been done. This vicious cycle continues to claim the lives of more and more people as the play progresses. Tituba attempts to tell the truth about Abigail when she says, You beg me to conjure! The turmoil in Salem is propelled forward by desires for revenge and power that have been simmering beneath the town's placid exterior. Is hypocrisy a natural state of the human mind? - Quora The two characters that could have ended the mass hysteria are Abigail Williams and Deputy Governor Danforth. How is Millers underlying message revealed in one of these themes and through the character?". Every person has some kind of flaw; no one is completely perfect. People are quick to believe something even if there is no evidence for their fear. As we discussed in this lesson, we see hypocrisy everywhere, and its depiction in art is no exception. Hypocrisy: A Human Flaw Okay, let's take a moment to review. Furthermore, this is destructive influence because by telling Elizabeth to tell Proctor to lie, this adds upon his sins. is hypocrisy a natural human flaw the crucible. Hypocrisy is not simply failing to practice those virtues that one preaches, or known as saying one thing but doing another. The power of collective hysteria ultimately becomes insurmountable because it grows larger than the influence of the few rational voices in the community. In addition to grubbing for a few extra pounds every year, Parris makes a show out of needing golden candlesticks for the altar to replace the pewter ones that have served the church since it was built. Concern for reputation is a theme that looms large over most of the events in. This makes him particularly averse to accepting that he's been fooled by a teenage girl. Why does Mary Warren warn John about testifying against Abigail? Like a struck beast, he says, and screamed a scream that a bull would weep to hear. The depths of the hysteria that has gripped Salem are revealed in Act 3 when John finally confronts the court. A character named Abigail lived with proctor and his wife and his two sons. What Are The Human Flaws In The Crucible 1560 Words | 7 Pages. The first is that she is looking to escape . I'll give a short summary of how each plays a role in the events of The Crucible. The Devil is precise.'' He is appalled by Elizabeths lack of emotion when he asks her to help the court get a confession out of her husband (pg. Choose a single character and discuss how this person embodies one of the themes. The people who preside over the trials are corrupt. The petition he presents to Danforth is used as a weapon against the signers rather than a proof of the innocence of Elizabeth, Martha, and Rebecca. While I speak Gods law, I will not crack its voice with whimpering (pg. Greed is a sin in the Puritan religion, so the people who supported the accusations were indeed hypocrites. She continues to act under the assumption that his reputation is of the utmost importance to him, and she does not reveal the affair. They could either confess to being guilty and is punished and put into jail or deny any relationship with the devil and be hanged and killed. John And Elizabeth Proctor's Flaws In The Crucible | Studymode Here again, he is driving the point home that the villagers were greedy and seeking land, so they put some of the pillars of the community to death for their own gain. Abigail's version of events is held to be true even after John confesses to their affair in a final effort to discredit her. Here are a few discussion questions to consider after you've read my summary of how the theme of reputation motivates characters and plot developments in The Crucible: If you're an old beggar woman who sometimes takes shelter in this creepy shack, you better believe these jerks are gonna turn on you as soon as anyone says the word "witch.". Anns extreme conclusions are gradually accepted because rational people are too afraid to challenge the consensus and risk bringing accusations upon themselves. We saw that Arthur Miller used the Puritans in The Crucible to explore the themes, or main ideas of a text, in order to make the statement that society can be hypocritical and that we should question intentions. officials (like Danforth) unable or unwilling to listen to reason? The whole purpose of a trial is to hear both sides of the story before a verdict is reached. This is taken as evidence that things are really getting out of control ("if Rebecca Nurse be tainted, then nothing's left to stop the whole green world from burning." A theme is a central topic that is addressed by a work of literature. Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support. 71). Thus demonstrating how mob mentality can impact an individual and ultimately drive the action of the play. 119). Miller writes: ''As for Rebecca herself, the general opinion of her character was so high that to explain how anyone dared cry her out for a witchwe must look to the fields and boundaries of that time.'' Proctor changes from a normal citizen and sinner to a tragic hero with a high sense of morality. The book is about witchcraft or what the town thinks is witchcraft. Well, it's not. Essay prompts will ask about these themes in a variety of different ways. He is somewhat responsible for all of the witch trials; if he wouldn't of committed adultery with Abigail, she wouldn't have gone on her rampage of blaming people. Of course, we know that Danforth has been trading peoples lives for lies this whole time. They are extremely biased towards believing they have made the correct sentencing decisions in court thus far, so they are reluctant to accept new evidence that may prove them wrong. For example, Bridget Bishop dressed in red, a color that was abhorrent in the Puritan eyes. John finally comes to the realization that Mary's truthful testimony cannot compete with the hysteria that has taken hold of the court. Shes not a traditionally accepted target like the others (except in her susceptibility as a woman to the misogyny that runs rampant in the play). Are We All Hypocrites? | Psychology Today The Bible that the Puritans swore to live by is not being honored when they used the trials to condemn their neighbors to death. "She sat to dinner in Reverend Parris's house tonight, and without word nor warnin' she falls to the floor. She was seen as a grandmother to the village. 129). As much as I loved Bernie Sanders, he made millions of dollars while preaching for democratic. I highly recommend you use this site! In The Crucible, there are many characters that feed into or contribute to the rapid spread of witch hysteria in the small village of Salem. He is known for making the right decisions and never going against them. Along with the final say in the putting to death of people during the Salem witch trials. A 17-year-old girl named Abigail Williams had an affair with John Proctor, a wealthy, married man. In the play The Crucible, Arthur Miller repeatedly portrays that duplicity and deceit are a natural part of human lives. In one of the most well-known quotes in the play, John Proctor angrily insists that the little crazy children are jangling the keys of the kingdom (pg. I propose that each and every one of us is, or at some time has been, guilty of hyopcrisy. The attitudes towards women in the 1950s, when the play was written, are evident in the roles they're given. John Proctor sabotages his own reputation in Act 3 after realizing it's the only way he can discredit Abigail. Each new false confession is thrown onto the pile of evidence of a grand Satanic plot, and as the pile grows larger, the hysteria surrounding it is fed generously. ACT Writing: 15 Tips to Raise Your Essay Score, How to Get Into Harvard and the Ivy League, Is the ACT easier than the SAT? Arthur Miller used this notion of hypocrisy when he wrote The Crucible to show us the theme, or underlying message, that a hypocritical society can be dangerous. Being in contact with someone else means mediating between ourselves and the other. How do the actions of authority figures encourage the girls to continue their accusations and even genuinely believe the lies theyre telling? Based on the background knowledge of the time, slaves were not considered part of the class system, so she was not valued as a community member. Giles got arrested for contempt. By Act 2, there are nearly 40 people in jail accused of witchcraft. references the many sentencing decisions he has already made in the trials of the accused. The College Entrance Examination BoardTM does not endorse, nor is it affiliated in any way with the owner or any content of this site. This confess or die mindset is one of the central ironies of the play. Hypocrisy is just one of many personality traits along many spectrums. John Proctor's Dilemmas In The Crucible | ipl.org Essay about Human Flaws in Arthur Miller's The Crucible Hypocrisy is "the practice of claiming to have moral standards or beliefs to which one's own behavior does not conform". Ann Putnam jumps at any opportunity to blame supernatural forces for the deaths of her children. Lying- Explain why the girls are more willing to lie . In Act 3, Hale continues to make ironic statements about the existence of concrete proof for the accusations of witchcraft. This lie essentially condemns both of them. And he goes to save her, and, stuck two inches in the flesh of her belly, he draw a needle out." She says, "My name is good in the village! Even before Abigail makes accusations, rumors of witchcraft have morphed into accepted truths in the minds of the more superstitious members of the community. . Answer (1 of 7): In that all states of mind occur due to the nature of the brain, yes, hypocrisy is natural in people with that tendency. The authorities ignore any inconvenient logical objections to the proceedings because they, too, are swept up in the madness. These hypocritical actions take away from the authority of the person or people committing them. Elizabeth is a victim of cruel irony in this Act when she is summoned to testify on the reasons why she dismissed Abigail from her household. In Act 2, the value of reputation in Salem starts to butt heads with the power of hysteria and fear to sway peoples opinions (and vengeance to dictate their actions). She has the power to utterly destroy peoples lives with a single accusation because she is seen as a victim and a savior. A Comprehensive Guide. Abigails presence is always rife with irony in. The accusers cannot present concrete evidences, and their wrongful convictions must be further scrutinized. What is the writer attempting to convey to the viewer? Why doesnt John immediately tell the court that he knows Abigail is faking? Hypocrisy, actually, didn't have a bad meaning until hypocrisy met politics in the 4th century B.C. Why do certain characters seem to be blind to the irony of their actions (Abigail, Danforth)? Why is Cheever both astonished and afraid when he finds the poppet with the needle in it? Her goal is to help students adopt a less stressful view of standardized testing and other academic challenges through her articles. The irony is that, in the face of Johns rejection, Abigail turns around and creates her own lies soon after that give her increased control over the society she resents. Hale also makes some unintentionally ironic statements in Act 1 when he begins his investigation. 133). Recall that hypocrisy is when someone's actions don't match up with the professed values. As Abigail begins to be accused she is pressured to deter from the truth. In the play there was a character by the name of John Proctor; Proctor was a family man that made a huge mistake. By Act 2, there are nearly 40 people in jail accused of witchcraft. This act also sees the irony of Hale discussing the powers of the dark that are attacking Salem (pg. Psychological Research & Experimental Design, All Teacher Certification Test Prep Courses, The Crucible: Author & Historical Context, The Crucible Introduction & Act Summaries, 12th Grade English Curriculum Resource & Lesson Plans, 11th Grade English Curriculum Resource & Lesson Plans, Study.com ACT® Reading Test Section: Prep & Practice, AP English Language: Homeschool Curriculum, College Composition for Teachers: Professional Development, CLEP Analyzing & Interpreting Literature: Study Guide & Test Prep, Humanities Survey for Teachers: Professional Development, Study.com ACT® English Test Section: Prep & Practice, Effective Summaries of a Paragraph or Passage, Chaucer's The Pardoner's Tale: Summary & Analysis, Palindromes in Music: Definition & Examples, Chamber Music: Definition, Instruments & Composers, Coloratura: Definition, Arias & Technique, Composer Gioachino Rossini: Biography, Music, Operas & Style, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community. makes them feel the best about themselves. Though the Puritans believed that children were not to be taken seriously, they are later convinced by the court officials that the children are the authorities on witchcraft. No one even considers Mary's statement about sticking the needle in herself. It helped me pass my exam and the test questions are very similar to the practice quizzes on Study.com. The Crucible is set during the Salem Witch Trials of 1692. Want to improve your SAT score by 160 points or your ACT score by 4 points? In reality, he is constantly judging himself, and this leads to outbursts of anger against others who remind him of what he did (he already feels guilty enough!). As this hysteria begins to rise, other people such as Thomas Putnam, a rich landowner, start to also allege Salem villagers. This vicious cycle continues to claim the lives of more and more people as the play progresses. SAT is a registered trademark of the College Entrance Examination BoardTM. Parris begs Danforth to postpone their hangings because he fears for his life if the executions proceed as planned. The fear caused by the thought of supernatural evil in Salem causes the characters in the play to turn a blind eye to logic and instead believe in claims not backed by actual "hard as rock" proof. We hear a lot about hypocrisy, or when someone's actions don't match up with the professed values. Lust and pride were John Proctors tragic flaws, lust is of course, one out of the seven sins. Abigail insists that she did nothing to deserve it and tries to put all the blame on Elizabeth Proctor. Believer, Baltimore City IEP Chair, and 2:39 marathon runner. He is weak and vulnerable after Abigail's theft of his life's savings, and hes even facing death threats from the townspeople as a result of John and Rebecca's imminent executions. Examples Of Weak In The Crucible - 444 Words | Internet Public Library These types of statements made by Hale earlier in the play become even more ironic in Act 4 when he realizes he made a horrible mistake by trusting the evidence that was presented to him. Abigails presence is always rife with irony in The Crucible, as she constantly chastises others for sins she herself has committed. Concern for reputation is a theme that looms large over most of the events in The Crucible. By examining the characters of the play, I believe that the three major characters who should be blamed the most for the witch trials are Abigail Williams. In high school, she earned a 2400 on the SAT, 5's on all seven of her AP tests, and was named a National Merit Scholar. -Hypocrisy is the state of falsely claiming to possess virtuous characteristics that one lacks. The desire to preserve and gain power pervadesThe Crucible as the witch trials lead to dramatic changes in which characters hold the greatest control over the course of events. Danforth is convinced that there is a moving plot to topple Christ in the country! and anyone who doubts the decisions of the court is potentially involved. Though their Bible would forbid murder, they condemn people to death with an excuse of witchcraft just to get land. Hale doesnt realize that his own fears and suspicions are the real powers of the dark. Character Flaw List: 30 Intriguing Character Flaws | Now Novel Arthur Miller pokes fun at this in his commentary in the play and explains his intentions to the audience. To Danforth, anything that doesnt confirm that he was right all along is a lie. The only power they have left is in refusing to confess and preserving their integrity. When she cant get John to abandon Elizabeth for her, she decides to take matters into her own hands and gain control through manipulating the fears of others. Abigails many deceptions are sometimes laughably ironic as she chastises others for lying even as she is spinning falsehoods. A professor tells us that he has a strict rule about cell phones in the classroom, then he answers it midway through his own lecture. This immaculate proof that has led him to sign numerous death warrants is nothing but the fabrications of teenage girls and other townspeople seeking petty revenge. Where before she was just an orphaned teenager, now, in the midst of the trials, she becomes the main witness to the inner workings of a Satanic plot. Later in the play, she is accused. In Act 2, John Proctors guilt over his affair with Abigail is demonstrated through an ironic exchange with Reverend Hale. Many of the conflicts that occurred in the play were caused by Abigail Williams. The accused people of Salem are all innocent and have nothing to do with neither witchcraft nor convening with the devil. The human lust and want for power has been and is the base of each and every witch-hunt. The people in charge are so eager to hold onto their power that if anyone disagrees with them in the way the trials are conducted, it is taken as a personal affront and challenge to their authority.